Monday, August 19, 2019
The Chemistry of Knowledge Essay -- Philosophy Knowledge Knowing Plato
The Chemistry of Knowledge Hippeas thought he had all the answers. ââ¬Å"I have never found any man who was my superior in anything,â⬠he boasted. Then he meets Socrates. Though he had made thousands of public speeches about virtue, a dialogue with the wisest of Athenians leads Hippeas to confess that he ââ¬Å"cannot even say what [virtue] isâ⬠(Hippeas 70). Lesser Hippeas discredits Hippeas but offers little more than a negative definition of knowledge. Meno, Phaedo, and the Republic provide a more comprehensive discussion of the definition, the good and the teaching of knowledge. The following pages will explore Platoââ¬â¢s theory of knowledge and will conclude with an examination of organic chemistry at Swarthmore College. According to Plato, knowledge requires the reasoned understanding of essences. To know the qualities something possesses, one must grasp ââ¬Å"what something isâ⬠(Meno 60). Knowledge entails an active understanding capable of weathering the rigors of a probing discussion. In Lesser Hippeas, Socrates uncovers the knowledge deficit underlying Hippeasââ¬â¢ opinions and skills. Plato makes a clear distinction between Hippeasââ¬â¢ mastery of facts and the possession of true knowledge: ââ¬Å"I certainly do not think I am guessing that right opinion is a different thing from knowledgeâ⬠(90). Facts and opinions require little more than memorization and regurgitation. Acquiring knowledge, on the other hand, can only be done ââ¬Å"with an effortâ⬠(Republic 776). Platoââ¬â¢s Cave analogy in the Republic likens the path to knowledge to the transition from a dark cave to a sunny hilltop. Plato allegorizes the ââ¬Å"ascent of the soulâ⬠(776) from a world of shadows, reflections and half-truths into the ââ¬Å"world of knowledgeâ⬠(776). Plato maintains that cave dw... ...nt of the reason whyâ⬠(90). Only knowledge boasts longevity. For me, perhaps the most disconcerting thing about organic chemistry is the rapidity with which my memory of it has faded. Some three months removed from a final exam, I recall virtually nothing. So why donââ¬â¢t we get knowledge, if it would serve us so much better than limited-warranty opinions? Thinking takes time. And there are only fifteen weeks to a semester. Professors need empirical measurements of student progress in finite periods of time, even when it is clear that cursory thought emasculates knowledge. After all, ââ¬Å"All late papers will be penalized" Professor Richard Schuldenfrei Works Cited Plato. Five Dialogues : Euthyphro, Apology, Crito, Meno, Phaedo. Trans G. M. A. Grube. Hackett Publishing Company, 2002. Plato. The Dialogues of Plato. Trans. B. Jowett. New York: Random House.
The Empire Strikes Back Essay -- French Revolution, French Society
Franceââ¬â¢s revolution of 1789-1799 destroyed the age-old monarchy, eliminated aristocratic privilege, and established the inalienable rights of all citizens. Dedication to the ideals of equality and freedom for all men is enshrined in the national motto, ââ¬Å"libertà ©, à ©galite, fraternità ©.â⬠Regardless of Franceââ¬â¢s longstanding commitment to the principles of liberty, contemporary social attitudes and policies have fallen far from the revolutionary ideal, particularly vis-à -vis Franceââ¬â¢s burgeoning population of immigrants and their descendants. Despite its extensive and tortuous history of immigration, twenty-first century France remains vehemently committed to antiquated notions of citizenship and national belonging. Franceââ¬â¢s persistent refusal to acknowledge its de-facto multiculturalism has created a brutal cycle of marginalization, in which ethnic minorities are prevented from expressing their cultural identities and successfully in tegrating into mainstream French society. Immigrants from the Maghreb ââ¬â a hilly, arid region in North Africa situated between the Atlas Mountains and the Mediterranean Sea ââ¬â represent the largest segment of Franceââ¬â¢s considerable ethnic population. France is currently home to over 3.5 million foreigners, more than a million of whom are Magrà ©bins, primarily from Algeria and Morocco (Sekher 25). Contemporary Magrà ©bin immigration began in earnest in the years following World War II. After defeating Germany, the United States launched an ambitious program to revitalize the devastated economies of Western Europe and create dynamic markets for mass-produced American consumer goods. From 1948-1951, The European Recovery Program, commonly known as the Marshall Plan, provided unprecedented levels of developm... ...ologist Franà §ois Dubet notes, ââ¬Å"Une socià ©tà © construite sur une à ©galità © des chances parfaitement juste pourrait, en mà ªme temps, à ªtre parfaitement inà ©galitaireâ⬠(qtd. in Rosello 237). To provide special benefits to minorità ©s visibles would undermine the egalitarian ideal of ââ¬Å"republican assimilationâ⬠by treating them as more than equals. Such reverse discrimination would represent an unacceptable breach of the sacred credo of ââ¬Å"libertà ©, à ©galite, fraternità ©.â⬠Hence, minorità ©s visibles generally receive an insufficient level of social spending, with derelict public housing projects and minimal welfare payments the only programs currently providing benefits (Smith 176). Continued adherence to outdated concepts of citizenship therefore facilitates the separate and unequal treatment of minorità ©s visibles by concealing persecution under the guise of official equality.
Sunday, August 18, 2019
Ghosts â⬠Seeing is Believing :: Personal Narrative, Autobiographical Essay
Ghosts ââ¬â Seeing is Believing à à à I live in a ghost hallway. They come and go whenever they want, like the transparent, blow-away wings of bees. Their spirits hover inside this house on Mechanic Street like a twilight hue filling a wine glass. I live more or less inside their moods, which they carry behind them in traces of light that flood the panes one window at a time and the creaky flutes of rusty hinges. The ghosts don't say ââ¬Å"booâ⬠and they don't swing chains. They're good ghosts as far as I can tell, calm as a cup of tea, considerate and watchful and able to pay attention to the least thing for many hours. I like how they watch me read without telling me what to think; I like how they touch my mind with ghost memories, laughing and smoking on the porch with their neighbors. I like how they stared out these same windows serious and alone in their own thoughts, unable to share with each other the deepest parts of themselves because the inner commotion was too great to put into words. I s ee how after a fight or death in the family they sat by themselves in the living room, wanting things to be good again, wanting to be healed but not being able to do anything but wait. à à à à à à à à What they have left behind is shorn of all eventfulness as if what happened here long ago in this quasi-dilapidated shotgun house still lingers on as after-tone slowly turning into something else, the echo of their memories which I navigate now with a cup of coffee and a three-day beard. I'm doing a soft-shoe in my slippers through their long recollections, the fog that hangs in the trees between dreams. They heard the same front door whine and clatter and the soft thudding of footfalls on the sidewalk: they heard the wind in the trees and the wash of rain tearing through them on its way to another season carrying a hundred small deaths in its wake. Their senses are alive in mine, just as mine are remade in the memory of theirs. It's a mysterious transference that I do not understand. I don't necessarily like to feel the pangs of sorrow the woman felt that beetled up and down her spine like a slug of mercury, finding her defenseless in her own house at different times in her life, like a painful sickness that keeps coming back. Ghosts ââ¬â Seeing is Believing :: Personal Narrative, Autobiographical Essay Ghosts ââ¬â Seeing is Believing à à à I live in a ghost hallway. They come and go whenever they want, like the transparent, blow-away wings of bees. Their spirits hover inside this house on Mechanic Street like a twilight hue filling a wine glass. I live more or less inside their moods, which they carry behind them in traces of light that flood the panes one window at a time and the creaky flutes of rusty hinges. The ghosts don't say ââ¬Å"booâ⬠and they don't swing chains. They're good ghosts as far as I can tell, calm as a cup of tea, considerate and watchful and able to pay attention to the least thing for many hours. I like how they watch me read without telling me what to think; I like how they touch my mind with ghost memories, laughing and smoking on the porch with their neighbors. I like how they stared out these same windows serious and alone in their own thoughts, unable to share with each other the deepest parts of themselves because the inner commotion was too great to put into words. I s ee how after a fight or death in the family they sat by themselves in the living room, wanting things to be good again, wanting to be healed but not being able to do anything but wait. à à à à à à à à What they have left behind is shorn of all eventfulness as if what happened here long ago in this quasi-dilapidated shotgun house still lingers on as after-tone slowly turning into something else, the echo of their memories which I navigate now with a cup of coffee and a three-day beard. I'm doing a soft-shoe in my slippers through their long recollections, the fog that hangs in the trees between dreams. They heard the same front door whine and clatter and the soft thudding of footfalls on the sidewalk: they heard the wind in the trees and the wash of rain tearing through them on its way to another season carrying a hundred small deaths in its wake. Their senses are alive in mine, just as mine are remade in the memory of theirs. It's a mysterious transference that I do not understand. I don't necessarily like to feel the pangs of sorrow the woman felt that beetled up and down her spine like a slug of mercury, finding her defenseless in her own house at different times in her life, like a painful sickness that keeps coming back.
Saturday, August 17, 2019
Dbq French and Indian War Essay
Before 1754, both the French and British had huge masses of land in America. Also sharing the land, was the natives, who were exceedingly nervous about the Englishmen taking away their land. This conflict eventually led to the French and Indian war, also known as the Seven Years war (1754-1763). The French and Indian war altered the political, economic, and ideological relations Britain and itââ¬â¢s American colonies in many ways where it ultimately led to the American Revolution because of the strain that was developed between them. The French and Indian war altered the political relations between Britain and itââ¬â¢s American colonies because of what happened before and after the French and Indian war. Before the war, the British had let colonists be and do whatever they wanted. But after the war, Britain had gained more land, as seen in Doc. A, and salutary neglect ended. This then brought up a feud on colonistââ¬â¢s representation in Parliament. To control the colonists, a British army was put in place that they told everyone was for their own protection from the Natives. The Proclamation Line was also executed, which was that a imaginary line that separated the colonists and the Natives(Doc. B). The British saw this a protection for the colonists, but it was actually just a negative for those saving up to buy land in new territory. Having the British soldiers guard the colonists from the natives became expensive, so the Quartering Act was put into place to make sure that every soldier would have a place to stay and then, the Restraining Act was enforced to make the colonistââ¬â¢s pay for the soldiers. This only enraged the colonists more because they were forced to house and support the enemy that was sent to take away their rights. All British relations in politics with the Americans were ruined because of acts put in place, causing the colonistââ¬â¢s to want to separate from Britain. The French and Indian war eventually slid the British back into a economic recession. They had to find a way to get their money back from the war. In Britainââ¬â¢s mind, the only logical place to get the money was from the American colonists because the money was technically spent on them, as seen in Doc. F. But The British was not expecting the hostile response from their Stamp Act and having to pay for the war damages. The colonists have never been taxed before, and they couldnââ¬â¢t understand why they had to pay without having representation for themselves. The Stamp Act really affected every colonist because they were forced to pay for every day items. The Stamp Act Congress sent appeals to Britainââ¬â¢s government to try to convince them of the insanity of the act, but the government was not going to change their mind(Doc. G). While going against the Stamp Act, the Colonists mocked the act by placing skulls in the place where the stamp on documents and letters would go(Doc. H). It was clear from the American response that they were not going to just give up and let the English tax them without a clear fight. Both the colonists and the British both had their different opinions, which created an even stronger strain between them, reeling in the American Revolution closer and closer. The ideological relations between the colonists and the British were undeniably a part of the developing strain after the French and Indian war. Before the war, North America was where the former England settlers went, and they still considered themselves as a part of their homeland(Doc. E), until the England government taxed the colonists and not their country as a whole(Doc. F). The colonists changed their ideology about staying loyal to their mother country because of this and slowly started to drift towards rebellion. The Natives also were about of the developing strain between the British and the colonists. The Natives were solely afraid that the British would take their land for farming, and they thought that the British people had no right to settle there(Doc. B). And then, after the Proclamation line was present, the military had come in to protect the colonists, but it is proven true that the armies were seen as scum (Doc. D). The American colonists just wanted equality and liberty from the British empire, but it was obvious that they werenââ¬â¢t going to get that because of the British taxes and not letting further settling in the other parts of the American land. Both of these contributions led to the colonists wanting to succeed from the British empire. The French and Indian war changed the political, economic, and the ideological relations between Britain and itââ¬â¢s American colonies because of the developing strain that eventually led to the American Revolution.
Friday, August 16, 2019
Not Enough Time to Spend with Family Members Essay
One doesnââ¬â¢t have to look far, in current circumstances throughout the world, to see that people are migrating from one country to another to earn bread and butter. There is a widely held view that, due to this trend, vast numbers of people are not able to spend quality time with their nearer and dearer ones. Similar to every other trend, there is no exception in this case also that it has its own ups and downs. To begin with, it is abundantly clear that due to globalization, opportunities are not limited to one corner of the world. Simultaneously intensive competition is present for each such chance. To prove mettle, Individuals are ready to sacrifice their family memberââ¬â¢s feelings, joy and agree to work on remote location without family. Moreover, parents are forced to celebrate festivals, birthdays and auspicious days without their kids. Last but not least, they feel gap in life when their kids are not around during their bad phase. At the other end of the spectrum, it brings sense of satisfaction when caretakers see their kids, who are now grown human being, working with multinational organizations. Due to higher wages and salary, they can afford luxurious items like car and furniture. In my personal experience, I have seen that my parents are now living affluent and comfortable life. This is largely due to my increased income which happened when I move to Australia from India. However, we missed each other during celebrations and functions At the end of the day, I pen down saying that once has to be flexible to survive in this world which is now running on 24X7. I strongly believe that separation for short time can bring happiness for long time.
Thursday, August 15, 2019
Narrative on Culture
Culture Crossing Do you ever look at a complete stranger and immediately categorize that person? I will be the first to admit that I have done so more than I would care to acknowledge. I was definitely raised to look down upon people, especially the Jewish, in spite of what my parents will tell you. Although I was never actually told not to like or associate with a Jewish person, the adults in my family made it known that it was unacceptable by saying unpleasant things about them. I heard the jewish would come to nice neighborhoods, take them over, and ruin them.I also heard that they killed Jesus. It was inevitable that I too would see Jewish people as inferior to me. With all the bad things I heard, it only seemed natural. I thought Jewish people were arrogant, greedy, conniving, and uneducated. I thought they should leave our country because their religion and cultural beliefs were un-American. From the time I was a little girl through my early twenties I looked down upon Jewish p eople until I met Joel one day while I was working. It was a typical Friday at the Department of Motor Vehicles.It was fifteen minutes until closing time and the place was packed. I was about to call my next customer when a short man dressed in black and white from head to toe with long chin-brushing curls as sideburns wearing a black hat approached my window. He was a Hasidic Jew and I was not happy. I acknowledged him. ââ¬Å"Yes? â⬠ââ¬Å"Are you going to call this ticket number? â⬠ââ¬Å"Nope. Have a seat,â⬠I said annoyed. ââ¬Å"I'm sorry to have bothered you. â⬠As he was sitting back down I noticed the ticket number he had in his hands. It was a dealer ticket. We stop calling dealers at 4:30 p. m because it's time consuming.I was contemplating if I was going to tell him this or let him find out the hard way. There was a big sign by the ticket machine that clearly states that we don't accept dealer paperwork after 4:30 p. m. Some of my coworkers noticed him and started making fun of his clothes, yiddish accent and, stupidity for not reading the sign. Although I tended to agree with them, I decided to be nice and help this man because I was sick and tired of hearing my coworkers ridiculing him. He was, after all, in hearing distance. I motioned the Hasidic man up to my window with my index finger. Sir, I normally would not help you because we don't accept dealers after 4:30 p. m but, I see you only have one deal so I will help you just this one time. â⬠He smiled from ear to ear and thanked me. I knew from experience that Hasidic men are not allowed to touch an object at the same time as someone from the opposite sex so, I was very surprised when he handed me the papers through the bars rather than sliding them underneath the window barrier. I didn't know what to do. Should I let the papers fall to the desk? I did not want to be impolite so I took the papers from him.After looking at his papers I soon realized that I would be u nable to process the transaction and I delivered the bad news to him. Expecting the worst, I was ready for the hostile reply I usually get from anyone I give unpleasant news to. Instead, he was polite and humble. He thanked me over and over for taking him. I was pleasantly surprised and smiled. I told him the additional papers he needed and even wished him a good evening. He was walking away when he turned and asked, ââ¬Å"What is your name? â⬠ââ¬Å"Annâ⬠I suspiciously replied. ââ¬Å"My name is Joel. Have a great weekend Ann!I will see you first thing on Monday,â⬠he said cheerfully as he walked towards the door. I wondered what was wrong with him. I had never came across a Hasidic man like him. As the metal gates lifted to the D. M. V entrance Monday morning, I noticed Joel was the first in line. He waved. Oh, geez. That was weird. My coworkers took notice of him and started to tease me. ââ¬Å"Look, there's Annie's special friend,â⬠said one. ââ¬Å"Annie' s curly locks is here,â⬠snorted another. I chose to ignore their snide remarks and called him up to my window. ââ¬Å"Good Morning Ann! How was your weekend? â⬠Joel asked.He placed a small tin of cookies on the counter. ââ¬Å"These are for you. They are from my brother's bakery in Brooklyn,â⬠he joyfully said as he slid the tin underneath the window bars. I told him that I couldn't accept them and thanked him. ââ¬Å"You have kids? Yes? Please take them home to your children then,â⬠he insisted. I took the cookies and hid them in my desk draw. ââ¬Å"Thank you Joel, that was very kind of you. My children will love the cookies. â⬠I hoped no one noticed the exchange. I did not want to be teased my coworkers. While editing and processing his paperwork, Joel started telling me jokes.They were funny but I didn't dare laugh because they were about the Jewish. ââ¬Å"Not all Hasidic's are extremists, Ann,â⬠he laughed. I didn't know how to respond. I never met a Hasidic man that was as friendly and talkative as Joel. I wondered if he was from Kiryas Joel, the village within the town of Monroe where it's residents strictly observe the Torah and its commandments. If he is, I'm thinking he shouldn't be talking to me like this. Hasidic men are proscribed from associating with woman who are not their wives or relatives. What if another Hasidic witnessed him talking to me? Joel, do you live in Kiryas Joel? â⬠I shyly asked. ââ¬Å"Yes, I do. Why do you ask? â⬠ââ¬Å"Um, can't you get in trouble for talking to me? â⬠I had a hard time getting the words out. I was embarrassed. ââ¬Å"I have many rules but it doesn't mean that I follow them to a T? â⬠I was intrigued. I knew little about Hasidism. I determined this would be an excellent opportunity to learn. ââ¬Å"Would you mind if I asked you questions about your religion? â⬠I quietly asked. Joel gave me permission to ask him anything. As time went on, I called hi m right up to my window.None of my coworkers wanted to help him anyway and, I looked forward to our conversations. I asked him questions about everything from having sex through a hole in the sheet to having a holiday that they are ordered to get drunk. Joel eagerly shared his experiences in detail leaving nothing out. He explained holidays, the importance of tradition, and beliefs. I learned the life of a Hasidic from birth through marriage. Joel educated me on why they dress all in black, what kind of education they receive, gender roles, acceptable entertainment, and any other aspect that I thought to ask him about.He explained the discipline involved to abstain mainstream American culture. When he spoke about his arranged marriage, I began to understand and respect the idea behind it. It did seem safer in the big picture because partners were picked that were good for a lifetime not short infatuations. I was amazed how open-minded I was becoming. I had gained respect for his rel igion and became quite fond of Joel. I saw him as a whole person rather than the Hasidic Jew I once seen. My religious and cultural upbringing fostered my ignorance.I grew up feeling superior to people outside my culture and religion because I simply didn't know any better. Meeting Joel changed my view on culture and religion. Through sharing his traditions and beliefs, I realized that other cultures interact differently and it's often misconceived as rudeness, anger and, foolishness. Getting to know Joel made me see that our cultural and religious beliefs didn't make us any less or any more of a person. Based on our common humanity, I learned to respect cultural and religious diversity.
Wednesday, August 14, 2019
Godââ¬â¢s Existence and Aquinas Objection Essay
I was in the debate team in high school. And there were times that our team would take the against side of the statement. In his famous work Prologion, written in 1077-1078, Anselm presents the idea the God exists because God is the greatest thing of all, that the idea of thinking of God exists prove its existence. Hundred of years later, Thomas Aquinas brings up the account that addresses Anselmââ¬â¢s idea in objection 2 of Question II, First Article of Summa Theologica. Aquinas objects Anselmââ¬â¢s argument later in his work by attacking the idea that God is something that can be thought greater. To understand Anselmââ¬â¢s argument for Godââ¬â¢s existence, one must first understand the principles that forms the argument. The first principle is the claim that ââ¬Å"nothing greater can be thought. â⬠There is too types of existing, existing in understanding (existing0) and existing in reality (existing1). Then, we try to think of something is existing1. Anselm let ââ¬Å"somethingâ⬠be ââ¬Å"something than which nothing greater can be thought (NGT),â⬠or in another word ââ¬Å"a being than which nothing greater can be conceivedâ⬠according to the Proslogion. The very first act of thinking that something is existing1 serves as the basis of it existing0. Because in the process of trying to think of something greater, we already establish its existence0. For example, there is a flower A, existing1. This flower A is the most beautiful flower, that this flower is a NGT. In order to prove this flower is NGT, one has to think of all the flower he has seen, flower B, C, or D. In the process of searching through oneââ¬â¢s mind trying to think of a flower that is more beautiful than flower A, flower A already exists in oneââ¬â¢s mind, which is existing0. To open his argument, Anselm then said an example of NGT is God. The second principle is the principle of ââ¬Å"thinking of non-existing objects (Principle E). â⬠Anselm uses the example of a painter conceiving the drawing he will paint, then executing his plan in mind to make the painting exists in reality. To breakdown his argument, letââ¬â¢s begin with something that exists0. Because one has the ability to imagine that something exists0, one can also imagine that the same thing exists1. This priniciple is the most uncontroversial because it is just a matter of imagination. The fact that one has imagination allows him to imagine whatever he wants. For example, one imagines he won the lottery and has a million dollars. It is safe to say that one can proceed to think of that million dollars is existing1, regardless of if the million dollars truly exists1. Applying Principle E back to the argument of NGT, if one can imagine NGT in existence0, one can also go ahead and imagine NGT existing1. The third principle is ââ¬Å"thinking something greater than something (Principle G). This principle compares the greatness of existing0 and existing1. Anselm proposes that ââ¬Å"greatnessâ⬠has two faces: qualitatively and existentially. To further support his argument, Anselm implies that greatness qualitatively means everything positive, such as, more beautiful, more knowledgeable, more influential, etc. Base on this assumption, Anselm argues that, ââ¬Å"Suppose it exists in the understanding alone: then it can be conceived to exist in reality; which is greater. â⬠To apply this principle in daily life, one can relate to a million dollars example above. One can imagine having a million dollars in his mind, but that million dollars doesnââ¬â¢t exist1. In another case, one owns a millions dollars, which means that million dollars exists1. The rhetorical question here will be, which case is more appealing to you, which scenario is ââ¬Å"greater? â⬠Back to Anselmââ¬â¢s claim, the ââ¬Å"itâ⬠in his argument is, of course, NGT, which is God. That God exists1 is better than God only exists0 but not exists1. The next principle returns to the basic meaning of NGT. Principle N presents the idea ââ¬Å"if something can be thought to be greater than x, then x is not an NGT. â⬠Assume something is an NGT, nothing greater can be thought. If there is another thing that is greater then it. This ââ¬Å"somethingâ⬠is no longer an NGT. This principle is pretty self-explanatory. To put it in everyday examples, imagine the beautiful flower A is the most beautiful flower in the whole wide world. However, one found another flower more beautiful than A. Now A is no longer an NGT, regardless in existence0 or existence1. Now substitute God in for NGT in the equation. Because Anselm already claimed that God is an NGT, if one can think of something greater than God, God is no longer an NGT. According to the Proslogion, ââ¬Å"God cannot be conceived not to exist. ââ¬âGod is that, than which nothing greater can be conceived. ââ¬âThat which can be conceived not to exist is not God. â⬠The upcoming principleââ¬â¢s idea bases that of principle E. Principle T simply proposes the idea that ââ¬Å"an NGT can be thought. â⬠Because one has the ability to think of an object either exists0, exists1, or even both, one can also think of NGT existing0, existing1, or both. The idea that one can think of something is very broad and universal, that ââ¬Å"somethingâ⬠can simply be anything. The final piece of Anselmââ¬â¢s argument is Principle M. This principle presents the very vague idea that ââ¬Å"if something must be thought as existing1, then it exists1. â⬠If one must think of a flower exists1, then that flower does exist1. Now that all principles Anselm needed to support his argument that God exists are gathered, he begins his argument with a ââ¬Å"fool (thinker)â⬠that ââ¬Å"understands [God] is in his understanding; although he does not understand it to exist. â⬠To fully understand this argument, one has to accept Anselmââ¬â¢s assumption that God, indeed, is an NGT. The argument that the thinker has the ability to think of NGT existing1 is based on Principle E that if one can think of an object then he can think of it existing1. The idea of thinking NGT exists1 is ââ¬Å"greaterâ⬠than the idea of thinking NGT exists0 but doesnââ¬â¢t exist1 (Principle G); therefore, one can think of something greater than the NGT that exists0 but not in reality. However, this violates the basic meaning of an NGT (Principle N), nothing greater can be thought. So the idea that one can think of something greater than the NGT that exists0 but not in reality is contradictory to the fundamental element of an NGT. Which comes to the agreement that if one think of an NGT it is to be existing1. The conclusion implies the principle that one can thought of NGT exists1 (Principle T). Also, one can and must only think of an NGT exists1. This lead to the final conclusion. If one has no choice but think of something exists1, that something must be existing1 (Principle M). Therefore, an NGT, God, exists. Aquinas gives an condensed version account of Anselmââ¬â¢s argument in Summa Theologica. In objection 2 of question II, ââ¬Å"Whether the existence of God is self-evident? â⬠, Aquinas addresses the idea much abruptly. He first implies that Anselmââ¬â¢s idea of God is an NGT is equivalent to saying ââ¬Å"things are said to be self-evident which are known as soon as the terms are known,â⬠that the significant of the word ââ¬Å"Godâ⬠is nothing better can be conceived. He follows the account by stating that the word ââ¬Å"Godâ⬠ââ¬Å"exists actually and mentally is greater than that which exists only mentally. â⬠Therefore, if the word ââ¬Å"Godâ⬠is understood mentally it has to be understood to exist actually. Both Anselmââ¬â¢s argument of Aquinasââ¬â¢s account of it come to the same conclusion that God exists, that the thought of it existing lead to its real existence. Aquinas objects Anselmââ¬â¢s idea by stating that not everyone understands the word ââ¬Å"Godâ⬠will agree that it is an NGT. He follows his objection by stating: Yet, granted that everyone understands that by this name God is signified something than which nothing greater can be thought, nevertheless, it does not therefore follow that he understands that what the name signifies exists actually, but only that it exists mentally. Aquinasââ¬â¢s main objection is that the idea of NGT can be interpreted that it can only exists mentally. However, for Anselmââ¬â¢s argument to work, one has to understand that God can exists in reality; therefore, Aquinas further objects Anselmââ¬â¢s claim by stating those ââ¬Å"who hold God does not existâ⬠will not admit the fact that God is an NGT and it exists in reality. In Anselmââ¬â¢s defense, he based all his argument on the fact that God is ââ¬Å"a being than which nothing greater can be conceived. â⬠As a true believer of God, Anselm would have simply oppose those who does not believe in God has not fully understand the meaning of ââ¬Å"Godâ⬠; therefore, they fail to grasp the idea God exists in reality. If one understands God, he will be able to think of Godââ¬â¢s existence in mind then agree to think of it in reality. After reading excerpts both from the Proslogion and the Summa Theologica, I am more inclined to support Aquinasââ¬â¢s claim. Although I do not think Aquinas has successfully destroyed Anselmââ¬â¢s argument, I think there are more weak links in Anselmââ¬â¢s argument than that of Aquinasââ¬â¢s. The most apparent loopholes are Principle M and Principle G. First, Principle M states that if one has to think of something as existing1, then that something has to exists1. However, Anselm neglects the fact that what one believes exists1 does not has to be true. For example, children were told to believe Santa Claus exists in reality and many of them do believe that idea. The contradiction being what those children ââ¬Å"can and mustâ⬠think exists1, Santa Claus, does not exists1. Second, the positivity of ââ¬Å"greatnessâ⬠implied in Principle G is too vague. The concept of greatness of reality is ââ¬Å"betterâ⬠than that of in mind can be subjective. Just because one person thinks the existence in reality is greater than existence in mind does not equal others perception of greatness. With doubts in Principle M and Principle G, I think Aquinas has a stronger position compare to Anselm does.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)